Bike Collective Software: Difference between revisions

Revision as of 19:43, 11 October 2007

This is the collaborative project description for custom bike collective software.

Requirements

The software will be an open source component of a CMS system. The choices we already narrowed it down to are Joomla, Drupal, and Wordpress.
Component features and/or Modules will be built to handle needs of the various shops. These modules can be turned on and off through a GUI interface.
A very intuitive installer will be crucial to help get all the non-profits started using the software. It should have pre-programmed data-sets for common collective / cooperative types.
Internationalization via simple language file options.

CMS Systems

Here are some test systems you can experiment on. If you want a login, or even your own test site let Jonathan Morrison know.

Jonathan Morrison's Opinion

My background is in software engineering as is my degree. I actually installed Wordpress, Joomla, Drupal recently to compare them. Here is my honest opinion of each of them and their user groups. I take into account sustainability factors like, "sure I am a nerd, but if I wasn't here, could someone else cover it?"

Wordpress was by far the easiest to install and get running, however it lacks components and features to _easily_ do anything more than a blog. For example if you want to add a photo gallery, etc.,... One of my main observations is the user group that uses this is more graphic designers, not programmers. Another plus is that you, as a nonprofit, can get free hosting using Dreamhost, and they have a simple one-click-install for Wordpress. This makes upgrades really easy.

Drupal was by far the most difficult to install, however it is very universal. With flexibility comes complexity, so make sure you have a hard core nerd on staff before you commit to this one. I would for the Salt Lake City Bicycle Collective, but in the event I wasn't around, I can't see it being maintained properly. The user group for this tends to be people like me, geeks. As a result, the graphical templates aren't as impressive as other CMSs. One cool feature that Bike Geeks used is they made all the Chicago sites connect. One unique feature of Drupal is that a single installation of Drupal can run several sites. Sadly, Dreamhost does not support drupal, so installations are all on your own.

Joomla, while I have spent the most time with it is still my personal favorite. It has the largest user base, and more addons and templates than any other CMS out there. To be fair, the big downfall isn't in technical complexity, but what how things are named. There are 1000s of templates, components, modules, mambots out there, but you need to know what they are before you can use them. Another plus is that you, as a nonprofit, can get free hosting using Dreamhost, and they have a simple one-click-install for Joomla. This makes upgrades really easy.

Features

People Tracking

We need to track many different kinds of contacts. Given the differences in organizations, ideally no single type that is "hard coded" and the administrator can add and remove Contact Types.

Examples:

Local Business Contacts
Distributors
Board of Directors
Members
Customers
Earn-A-Bikers
Mechanics
Cooks
Clergy

Inventory Tracking

Hopefully we can generalize this as well.

Examples:

Fleet/Library/Yellow Bikes
New Parts
Used Parts
Tools
Rentals

Event Listing

Events could be meetings, open shop nights, valet bicycle parking, tabling festivals, etc.,...

Event Signups

This could be used to sign up for an event or could be used to keep track of people at an event.

Hour Tracking

For Volunteers and or Staff.

Recycling

?

Art

?

Software Life-cycle

Winter is a great time to get this rolling and hopefully have it ready for next spring.

Create the dev team Email List
Create a project description
Delegate programming / graphic design
Development Stage
Internal Testing / External Testing
Fix Bugs
Beta Release / External Testing
Fix Bugs
Final release
Maintenance / Feature Requests

Developers

Jonathan Morrison - Programmer, PHP, etc.,..
Rich Points - CSS/XHTML
Nathan Wilkes - Programmer, PHP

@@ Line 16: / Line 16: @@
 * [http://wordpress.bikecollectives.org/ Wordpress]
-=== Jonathan's Oppinion ===
+=== Jonathan Morrison's Opinion ===
 My background is in software engineering as is my degree.  I actually installed [http://wordpress.bikecollectives.org/ Wordpress],  [http://joomla.bikecollectives.org/ Joomla], [http://drupal.bikecollectives.org/ Drupal] recently to compare them.  Here is my honest opinion of each of them and their user groups.  I take into account sustainability factors like, "sure I am a nerd, but if I wasn't here, could someone else cover it?"